Bake
Crème Brûlée Pie
Popular on Food52
11 Reviews
Melissa C.
March 4, 2023
Ho. Lee. HECK. We had friends over for dinner last night and I made this for dessert. The custard is absolute perfection: rich, creamy, dreamy. I’ve made nearly all of Erin’s pies — both published here and in The Book on Pie — and I think this is among her best (so good, I baked a second one this morning).
Lynn D.
November 26, 2021
What's not to love...pie + creme brûlée? My only cooking notes would be that the ratio of filling to pie crust was a little low, so it's worth 1.5x the recipe. I also decreased the sugar in the mix as it was too sweet for my taste.
Marcypainting
December 11, 2020
Loved it, be VIGILANT on jiggle at 25 minutes., a few minutes overdone likely as I forgot to check temp with thermometer. Writing in my cookbook of Erin’s every gram to ounce I googled to make after weighing. Nothing like a blow torch dessert in covid-19 quarantine 😊
Anita K.
November 26, 2020
I wish the recipe also stated grams and such, for the non Americans, tablespoons to measure butter is very weird to me.
mgracelalala
November 24, 2020
has anybody done this with just the broil setting in the oven? i don't have a blow torch...
Miss_Karen
November 24, 2020
I haven't used the broiler method for THIS recipe, but I do make regular creme brulee from time to time. The trick is TO WATCH IT. It can go from brulee to burned in mere seconds.
Luci C.
November 25, 2020
Can you make this the day before and then brûlée with the broiler before eating?
Miss_Karen
November 25, 2020
Yes, as far as I know you can let the guard cool, then put it in the fridge. Do the top just before you serve it. DON'T do the topping and then put it in the fridge. The sugar will liquify & it's not pretty.
lmh_Lilly
December 22, 2020
you likely could but I did the same with a creme brulee cheesecake and the edges of the crust burnt. The same would likely happen here.
See what other Food52ers are saying.